2 URGENT ACTIONS TO TAKE to protect our seeds before the 4th December!!!


There are 3 MEPs directly involved with the law who are really worth writing to:
(be nice to them though, it wasn’t their idea)

Sergio Silvestris: Rapporteur of the Committee for Agriculture and Rural Development
(he is chairing the making of the new law)


George LYON (United Kingdom) – Group of the Alliance of Liberals and Democrats for Europe – ALDE


Julie GIRLING (United Kingdom) – European Conservatives and Reformists – ECR


You can send the same email to all three of them. This is probably the key thing to do.
Here is an example – though it is better to put things into your own words.

Dear Mr Silvestris/ Mr Lyon / Ms Girling

Subject: Proposed new EU Plant Reproductive Material law

I am writing to you because I am worried about the proposed new law regulating the sale of seeds within the European Union.

Home gardeners have very different needs from farmers and larger scale growers. The law as it is currently drafted does not take account of this difference, and will result in far less choice of varieties suitable for gardeners.

I realise there are some exceptions allowed in the law for ‘niche market’ varieties, but these are much too limited.

This law is being described as for ‘consumer protection’ but there are no problems as things stand with home garden seed that we need protecting from. The new law will hugely reduce our choice of plants to grow. This is unreasonable given that it will not benefit us in any way.

It is not appropriate for seeds sold in small packets for individual gardeners to be regulated in the same way as seeds for commercial agriculture, and as a gardener, I do not want to be limited to growing varieties of vegetable developed for a completely different type of growing.

Home gardeners should be able to choose any vegetable variety they want to grow, in a free market, and not be restricted to a list of ‘approved’ varieties. Agriculture in the EU is a major business. Individual citizens’ gardens and allotments are a completely different sector, and don’t need the same degree of regulation.

I would ask you to change the draft law so that home garden seeds and plants are not covered by the new law.

I would be grateful for a reply to this letter

Yours sincerely

[your name]



The UK government have just started a consultation asking people what things should be covered by EU laws, and what should be decided at national level.
The consultation about agriculture is happening now.   We are asking as many people as possible to respond, and say that garden plants and garden seeds should NOT be covered by EU regulation, but instead controlled by UK laws.

DEFRA have a page of information about the consultation here: https://consult.defra.gov.uk/eu/boc-agriculture

And then the actual consultation – the bit to fill in – is here: https://consult.defra.gov.uk/eu/boc-agriculture/consultation

What to fill in?

NOTE: You don’t have to answer ALL of the questions on the form – just one is fine.

You could just make one brief point in 
Question 5 (in the section ‘EU Competence for Agriculture’)

We feel that the EU should not have competence for (that is, they shouldn’t make decisions about) Plant Reproductive Material(that is, seeds) intended for gardeners.
Agriculture in the UK (and the rest of the EU) is a major business. Individual citizens’ gardens and allotments are a completely different sector, and don’t require strict EU-level regulation.

You’ll need to put this in your own words, but the point to make to them is that it is not appropriate for UK gardeners to be regulated by the EU as if they were farmers, and that they have very different needs.  Garden plants and seeds should not be regulated in the same way as cereals and potatoes grown on hundreds of acres.

Help reading the background material to the consultation:

If you don’t want to read all the way through the DEFRA ‘Call for Evidence’ document, the key part relating to Plant Reproductive Material (= “seeds and cuttings” to most of us) is on page 20, paragraph 49.

Here is what DEFRA say there, explaining the current situation:

“Marketing of plant reproductive material is regulated by a number of EU directives.  These are consumer protection measures which set out the quality and identity requirements which seed and other plant reproductive material must meet before it may be marketed.  The objectives include encouraging the breeding and uptake of improved varieties, assuring seed quality for safe, reliable and environmentally efficient food production, and facilitating international trade.  The Directives also cover the marketing of ornamental plant material.  In recent years simpler requirements have been agreed for conservation varieties and varieties with no intrinsic value for commercial crop production eg varieties intended for gardeners.

We have marked the final sentence in bold –   These simpler regulations for garden seed are what the new EU Seed Law will abolish. This is what you need to comment on in Question 5 – Seed Regulation for home gardeners needs to be brought back into UK control.

If enough people fill in the survey, it is possible that the Seed Laws will be brought back to UK control!



4 thoughts on “2 URGENT ACTIONS TO TAKE to protect our seeds before the 4th December!!!

  1. The authors of this site may have very real reasons for tilting in favour of gardeners but they have clearly forgotten one very important fact. Subsistence farmers through out the EU deserve to also be given freedom to continue to grow and save their own seeds otherwise in time even you gardeners will capitulate to laws imposed by our own and the EU governments. Especially when the corporations bring up the argument that gardeners are contaminating farm seeds and force the EU/UK government to impose more laws. Who will stand with you then? The farmers? Doubt they will give you a second glance after you sold them out by looking after your own hides at their expense. Never heard of solidarity?
    Then we will have the corporations who run the seed registers demanding a patent and intellectual property right fee for every seed on the lists once the legislation is in place to include gardeners.
    Gardeners are miniature farmers. They are not a separate entity so do not try to distance yourself from the farming community.
    As for agriculture being a major business and gardening being something else you clearly do not realise just how profitable the gardening sector is to the UK economy. It is on a par acre for acre with agriculture.
    I practice permaculture and support agroecological farming techniques. Agroecological methods of food production need to be practised in gardens as well as in the larger agricultural settings. So stop trying to cut out the needs of the farming community. They are equally as important as gardeners. They deserve solidarity otherwise you are simply dividing yourselves and making it easier for the greedy fat cats to conquer you. Think before you isolate yourselves.

    Save seeds and save the future!
    Oxford Real Farming Conference 6/7th January 2014
    Seedy Sunday 2nd February 2014

    1. Dear Kevin
      Thank you for your comment and we have really no idea how you got to seeing that we in any way want to separate, leave out or isolate! We look forward to hearing more from you. In solidarity. Freedom Seed Bank

      1. Your campaign article at the very top is geared up for gardeners. That is where I got to seeing the separation between agriculture and gardeners. What hits one will inevitably hit the rest. Divided we will fall but together we just may overturn this corrupt act of biodiversity destruction by the equally corrupt governments and their corporate friends.

        I am fighting tooth and nail to stop the corporate takeover of every freedom we have be it the freedom to eat healthy food or grow it or even to encourage others to do so. Even the freedom to talk about all these things is under threat. So is our freedom to decide what happens to our country. If the corporations want to frack the countryside and we object they will have the legal powers to sue us for loss of profits if we stop them on environmental or human health grounds. If you doubt it check out the TTIP trade deal being negotiated.at this time.
        Before too long we will be hit from every angle with corporate thugs shouting and bawling at us for even thinking about growing our own food or criticising their masters activities. We will become nothing more than commodities to be bought and sold at will.
        The legal system is being rigged to favour the corporations and the future looks very dark indeed. So go and check out the TTIP (and the Pacific equivalent TPP) trade deal being currently negotiated. They give control of our futures to the corporations and we will not have a leg to stand on when they come calling.
        Their remit is simple….profit!
        Ours is simple……Survival!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s